Forums
Would following this format be appropriate for citing this online obituary posted on a furneral home's web page?
Obituary, laytonandersonfh (http://www.laytonandersonfh.com : accessed 24 March 2018), Alexander Hinshelwood, died 15 March 2018. query: Hinshelwood
http://www.laytonandersonfh.com/obituary?id=315593
The funeral home web page appears to maintain a database of "current obituaries" so I don't think you can search for previous obituaries, and it's not apparent how long these entries are available. I'm unsure if this type of web page, that temporarily keeps a searchable list of people for a limited time, needs special consideration in the citation. I've also seen hospitals maintain web pages of this nature for current births.
Also, if we'd consider this a database, am I supposed to be putting in a database name in the citation, and if so, what would you use?
dpslager, I’ll rearrange your
dpslager, I’ll rearrange your questions so that the answers to each will build on each other.
Name of Database
The left-side menu on the site's home page lists its different databases or modules or articles about the funeral home and its services. Whichever one of these we choose would be the name we use in the database/article field of the citation. In this case, the database or module is called “Obituaries.” You’ve appropriately begun your citation with that word. But it should be in quotation marks. In your citation template, you would place this word “Obituaries,” as the name of the database.
As a side hint here, citations to published materials don’t normally begin with a descriptive word telling what kind of source we are using--which is how the word obituary, without quotation marks, would be interpreted. Citations typically begin with the creator of the record. Or, if no creator is identified or if the name of the source is eponymous, then we don’t have to use the “creator” field of the citation. That’s the situation in this case.
Name of Website
You didn’t ask about this, but I’ll nitpick anyway. The name of the website is not laytonandersonfh. It’s Layton-Anderson Funeral Home.
Durability of Record and URL
You noted that this is a database of "current obituaries" and that "it's not apparent how long these entries are available." Experimenting with the id=315593 at the end of the URL, I tried lowering this number to see how far back I could go. id=1001 took me back to 2012, which seems to be the point at which the funeral home began putting obituaries online. It appears that Layton-Anderson started with the number 1001 and that it is not removing obituaries after some unspecified period of time.
On this basis, you might—instead of just citing the home page URL—use the URL that routes someone directly to Alexander Hinshelwood's page. Then you would not have to restate the name for which you are querying, which would eliminate a repetition.
All Things Considered
These tweaks would give us this citation:
“Obituary,” Layton-Anderson Funeral Home (http://www.laytonandersonfh.com/obituary?id=315593 : accessed 24 March 2018), Alexander Hinshelwood, died 15 March 2018.
Dear EE, I have read…
Dear EE,
I have read through the above example to help with my citation for an online service notice. I'm fairly confident with the first reference note but not sure about the source list entry. Can you advise which chapter in Evidence Explained (Third Edition) might help me with this?
https://ianjarthurfunerals.com.au/services/eric-henderson-grant
First Reference Note
“Upcoming Services,” Ian J. Arthur & Sons (https://ianjarthurfunerals.com.au/services/eric-henderson-grant : accessed 3 March 2024), Eric Henderson Grant, died 23 November 2020.
Thanks,
Renee
Hello, Renee. An obituary,…
Hello, Renee.
An obituary, in print or online, is essentially an article in a larger, standalone publication. In your case, that larger publication is the website. The obituary is the article at the website. In EE3 (or 4), turn to the QuickStart Guide at the front of EE, the page headed "The Basics: Publications: Print & Online," then the third item: "Website with Multiple Offerings."
One comment on your proposed reference note: When I use your URL, it does not lead to the page "Upcoming Services." (That's logical, because the service for Mr. Grant, who died in 2020, is no longer upcoming.) Your URL leads directly to a page headed "Eric Henderson Grant." Therefore, your citation could be streamlined to this:
"Eric Henderson Grant," obituary, Ian J. Arthur & Sons (https://ianjarthurfunerals.com.au/services/eric-henderson-grant : accessed 3 March 2024), died 23 November 2020.
Citing a Transcribed Oral…
Citing a Transcribed Oral History
I am not sure how to cite an oral history by one person (Person A) that was written down by another person (Person B), then this written account was transcribed by a third person (Person C). Who is the author or responsible party?
Thank you