Forums
In section 15.20, p. 681, "Newspaper Articles (Online Images)", I have a question about the way templates are specified for use. Building each by combining two base cases seems more prone to error than modifying an existing vetted composite template.
Is the end result basically Template 10a/b (depending on the presence/absence of a database/collection), with Template 4: Newspaper article taking the place of Template 9: Government & Office (Layer 1) content in that composite template? For me; to think of it this way makes more sense, as I can see the logic in simply replacing the "physical" layer in an already assembled and vetted composite template layout.
If this is the case, I can easily create "templates" for any number of physical items imaged online. It also ensures that my treatment of the online portion remains absolutely constant across all my online citations.
H-H, as pointed out in…
H-H, as pointed out in every edition of EE, at §2.1, "citation is an art, not a science." No two artists paint the same. Evidence Style presents a logical set of templates that history researchers have found workable for almost twenty years. But EE does not dictate that everyone must follow every jot and tittle. As 2.1 goes on to say:
As budding artists, we learn the principles—from color and form to shape and texture. Once we have mastered the basics, we are free to improvise. Through that improvisation, we capture the uniqueness of each subject or setting. As historians, we use words to paint our interpretations of past societies and their surviving records. In order to portray those records, we learn certain principles of citation—principles that broadly apply to various types of historical materials. Yet records and artifacts are like all else in the universe: each can be unique in its own way. Therefore, once we have learned the principles of citation, we have both an artistic license and a researcher’s responsibility to adapt those principles to fit materials that do not match any standard model.
With everything you use in the course of your research, you will use your own judgment—unless you submit your work to a publisher, in which case, your editor will make that decision.