Forums
Dear editor,
I have been working on a one-place-study in collaboration with another researcher. We both made copies at the archives, all marked with citations to the original source. He has now passed away and I have inherited his collection. I would like to know how to cite these photocopies.
In the case of using the photocopies that he created, "cite what you use" plus section 7.19 say that I need to cite the fact that it is a photocopy and how it came into my posession. That makes sense since I never handled the manuscripts myself and cannot vouch for it being where he said it was.
Would the situation be different if I used one of the photocopies that I made myself? In that case I handled the actual record although in most cases I did not actually study it at the repository as I am gathering entire volumes. I think most researchers that use manuscripts do a lot of their work of image copies that they created themself and I have never seen any reference to photocopies or digital photographs created by the researcher in peer-reviewed journals. Since I handled the original record, know that it existed and how it was referenced, and what the contents were, I think it would be safe to cite the original. Of course, I may have missed a page, so working off the copies I created introduces a small risk of errors compared to working from the original, which would argue for putting a note in.
My own way to handle this is to include a note about using the photocopies in my research notes, but leave that off for publication. Would that be a prudent strategy?
[just to clarify, my strategy
[just to clarify, my strategy to leave off the note about the photocopy would only apply to the photocopies I made myself, not those of the other researcher. 7.19 makes it very clear that I need to cite the paper trail]
Yvette,
Yvette,
The practices you describe are exactly what EE would recommend. As for any concern that you may have missed a page while "handling" the record, the odds are good that most of us miss something everytime we use a record!
Wonderful, thank you! I agree
Wonderful, thank you! I agree with you that we can make mistakes anytime we handle a record, whether it is browsing the manuscript or taking pictures. I hadn't thought of it that way, very helpful.