Citation Issues

Citation Using URL to Collection

I'm just wrapping my head around EE4 templates and explanations. One thing I find daunting is the use of full URLs to a document image in FamilySearch - if only because of the extreme length of some of them which makes final citations rather unwieldy.

Would this variation seem a reasonable alternative? It's patterned on how Ancestry census records are handled in EE4 using Template 5.

IrishGenealogy.ie databases

I saw some posts from 2016 (yikes! a whole decade ago!), and they did help with crafting this citation, but I'm always wondering if I'm missing anything.

Department of Culture, Communications & Sport, "Civil Records," database and images, Irish Genealogy (https://www.irishgenealogy.ie/search : accessed 15 Nov 2026), image, death registration of Michael Quin, 2 April 1904, Killaghteen, registered 7 April 1904, Geo. Peirce; citing Group Registration ID 4713404, Newcastle SR District/Reg Area.

Clarification needed re: Template 5, "Complex Website (Multiple Articles or Databases", p. 121

In "Template 5 - Complex Website (Multiple Articles or Databases)" there are three questions for which a brief answer would be very helpful. I don't see anything in the "Construction Notes" that addresses these questions.

1) If the "Descriptor" for the database is something like "database with images" and one only use the images, where does one note that in the template structure? Edition 3 had an "Item Type or Format" field that made this clear. Does this information now get subsumed by the "Specific Item field"?

Discrepancy in Sec. 3.4 vs. Template Definition tables.

Just an item for the errata list...

If the 14 Template definitions are considered correct, and they appear to be, then 3.4 The Basic Seven" numbered list appears to have reversed items 5. and 6. That is 5 should be "Publisher" and 6 should be "Date/Year".

Marriage Banns

When a marriage takes place by banns, the banns are read on three consecutive Sundays in the parish church(s) where the bride- and groom-to-be live. Sometimes they are recorded together with the marriage record, and sometimes in a separate Banns Book.

When citing the banns, do you include the date of the first reading, the last reading, or all three readings? My feeling is that the first reading is sufficient, because that would indicate where in the banns book to find the entry. But I may be wrong.

What are other people's ideas?

Differences in the Microfilm First Reference 3rd vs 4th edition

I'm trying to understand some specific of various templates and the components within them.  The first place I looked was Template 1 p129 (3.18) in ed.3  vs p152 (4.17) ed. 4 and the First Reference Notes do not match.

Edition 3

“Muster Roll of Captain [Joseph] Martin’s Company of Pittsyl-
vania Militia in 1774,” The Draper Manuscripts, microfilm edition, 123
rolls (Teaneck, New Jersey: Chadwyck-Healey, n.d.), roll 42, Series XX,
Tennessee Papers, vol. 1, p. 6.

Edition 4: